Central Indiana Fish and Seafood Markets
The Butcher's Block
They offer daily seafood arrivals, which are overnighted direct from the coasts. They can fill special orders and offer sustainable and wild caught options.
115 S. State Road 46, Ste. E | Bloomington | 812.336.6328
Caplinger’s Fresh Catch Seafood Market
Family owned and operated with over 125 years of combined staff experience in offering its customers “whatever you may be looking for that swims,” Caplinger’s can help you choose the fish that’s right for you. Standard seafood eats like crab and oysters sit alongside alligator and crawfish in their cases. You can grab a bite when you drop in – we recommend the fish sandwich (I’m sure you’re not surprised).
7460 N. Shadeland Ave., Suite 400 | Indianapolis | 317.288.7263
5009 Gray Rd. | Noblesville | 317.218.3221
Fresh City Market
Get a fresh juice and then find the seafood counter at this local grocery store near Purdue University. We like this quaint neighborhood grocery store and the products it offers. And did we mention it's open until midnight every day of the week?
720 Northwestern Ave., West Lafayette | 765.743.1413
Joe’s Butcher Shop and Fish Market
Joe’s specializes in fresh, whether it’s meats, seafoods or cheeses. We enjoy the wide and unique variety of seafood options – like Pacific blue marlin and wahoo fish – but also appreciate the more commonplace fish like white tuna.
111 W. Main St. | Carmel
Kona Jack’s Fish Market
You can’t go wrong with fish flown in daily that’s fresh and delicious. They offer lots of seasonal seafood options like salmon, scallops and crab legs, to name a few.
9419 N. Meridian St. | Indianapolis | 317.843.1609
Saraga International Grocery
If you haven’t been to Saraga, you should go for the experience alone. The store abounds with rows and rows of international far from fruits and veggies to cheeses and meats. And they offer a wide variety of fish options – you can even point to a fish in a tank and they will filet it right before your eyes.
3605 Commercial Dr. | Indianapolis | 317.388.9999
The Savory Swine
While the name may tell you the only have pork, they also offer an assortment of seafood options. While you're there, you can also pick from a wide selection of wine to go with your ocean fare and maybe you'd even like to try their gelato.
410 Washington St. | Columbus | 812.657.7752
Williamson Fish Market
Here you can drop by for fish and French fries made in house, or get fresh fish to go.
2935 Clifton St. | Indianapolis | 317.925.5915