Das Dutchman Essenhaus

Why We Love It: OK, we know it's not exactly close to drive up to Amish country in Northern Indiana, but if you live in Central Indiana it's worth the trip to make your way up to Middlebury to take in the countryside and pick up your family's Thanksgiving Dinner. You'll get turkey or ham, potatoes, handmade noodles, and handmade white or wheat dinner rolls. And you can choose from 27 varieties of pies. It's a road trip well worth it.