Sweet Talk in Carmel

By Gretchen Keene / Photography By Christina Richey | November 15, 2011
Share to printerest Share to fb Share to twitter Share to mail Share to print
Sweet Treats

Step inside Simply Sweet Shoppe in downtown Carmel and chances are you won't know where to look first.

The place is stocked from hardwood floors to ceiling with bulk bins and jars filled with brightly colored candies. Sophisticated chocolates and gift baskets catch the eye.

A seating area invites customers to enjoy their treats, plus coffee, hot chocolate and owner Jill Zaniker's very own sipping chocolate–a two-ounce pour best described as a creamy, melted truffle in a cup.

This is exactly what Zaniker, a Carmel native, envisioned when she set out to fill a retail niche.

"I really wanted people to have a place to come and relive childhood memories," she says. "And that's what the shop has become known for."

Jill Zaniker

Case in point: "I had a 90-year-old woman come in recently and she was just so delighted by the place. It took her right back to when she was a little girl," Zaniker says.

Zaniker, who has spent years in retail, opened Simply Sweet Shoppe in 2008 after being a stay-at-home mom for 12 years. In addition to offering retro candies, bulk items and novelty sweets (world's largest gummy worm, anyone?), Zaniker knew she wanted to seek out quality chocolate made in Indiana.

"I carry local items whenever possible," she says. "I strongly believe in supporting other small local businesses."

Today, the shop stocks everything from gourmet marshmallows made by 240sweet in Columbus to gluten-free cookies by BeeFree Bakery in Noblesville.


Simply Sweet Shoppe owner Jill Zaniker scouts for Indiana-made treats to sell at her store. Here are four of her favorites:

Uncle Henry's Candy

Carl Harvey's uncle Henry taught him how to make chocolate, and now Harvey is an Indiana Artisan–which means he's among the best at his craft in the state. He makes hand-cut turtles in Cicero, enrobing them in milk or dark chocolate for melt-in-yourmouth goodness. www.unclehenryscandies.com

BeeFree Bakery's Sugar Cookies
Chocolate-Covered Caramels Topped with Sea Salt by Best Chocolate in Town
BeeFree Bakery's Gingerbread Cookies
Photo 1: BeeFree Bakery’s sugar cookies
Photo 2: Chocolate-covered caramels topped with sea salt by Best Chocolate in Town
Photo 3: BeeFree Bakery’s gingerbread cookies

BeeFree Bakery cookies

These gluten-free sugar and gingerbread cookies made by Jennifer Wiese in Noblesville satisfy snackers whether they are health-conscious or not. www.beefreegf.com

Best Chocolate in Town

Zaniker describes Best Chocolate's chocolate-covered caramels topped with sea salt as "a little bit of heaven." Elizabeth Garber, also an Indiana Artisan, makes the chocolates by hand in downtown Indianapolis. www.bestchocolateintown.com

Cake pops

These bite-size treats are all the rage, and baker Meghan Grilliot makes them on-site. Simply put, they're balls of frosted cake on sticks, but Grilliot decorates them to the nines.

Article from Edible Indy at http://edibleindy.ediblecommunities.com/where-shop/sweet-talk-carmel
Build your own subscription bundle.
Pick 3 regions for $60