Mom’s Homemade Pies

Why We Love It: Mom’s Homemade Pies is one of the few pie shops in Indiana that makes its pie crust by hand. A mixer is never used at any stage of crust production. Owners Dave and Alyona Puckett say this is important because the use of mixers commonly “overworks” the dough producing a pie crust that is not tender and flakey. Mom’s Homemade Pies makes 13 different fruit pies, 14 different cream pies and a hearty chicken pot pie.