My Sugar Pie

Why We Love It: My Sugar Pie has received national attention for its sugar pie from People Magazine, Oprah Magazine and Country Living Magazine. The Sugar Pie is also a signature treat at the Zionsville Farmers’ Market, the Cobblestone Grill, both Harry and Izzy’s locations, St. Elmo Steakhouse and the Omni Hotel of Indianapolis. And it’s no wonder the pie is so popular considering everything is handmade, with a light, crispy crust that is from owner Kelly Maucere’s mother’s original recipe. My Sugar Pie also sells 27 different fruit pies, seven different meringue pies and five specialty pies. Pies can be shipped or purchased at the store whole or by the slice.