Edible Indy's Love(ly) Picks for Valentine's Day Reservations

Last Updated February 10, 2016
Share to printerest Share to fb Share to twitter Share to mail Share to print
Tinker Street Restaurant Indianapolis

Grab a date and make a reservation!

Love is in the air and if you are not making your Valentine a lovely romantic dish at home, perhaps a reservation will be the key to unlocking something special. They say the key to a good heart is through the stomach and we believe in this 100% - As our owner, Jennifer Rubenstein can attest, her husband asked her to marry him over a good meal - and we are certain someone will get engaged on this upcoming Valentine's Day. Make it special and head to one of our picks for a romantic, delicious and local meal.

The Loft Restaurant & Dairy Bar at Traders Point Creamery

Why We Love It: Set in a barn from the 1860s adjacent to the family farm and Indiana's first USDA-certified organic creamery, the Loft Restaurant is deeply connected to the land and local produce. The hand-hewn beams...
|9101 Moore Rd , Zionsville, IN, us
|(317) 733-1700

Tinker Street

Why We Love It: Find affordable dishes featuring local, seasonal ingredients at Tinker Street’s cozy location on 16th street. While they have plant-based, vegan and vegetarian options, they are also satisfying the...
|402 E. 16th St., Indianapolis, IN, us
|(317) 925-5000


Vida Indianapolis
Why We Love It: This unique to Indianapolis restaurant set up in the trendy Lockerbie Community near downtown is going to set your belly on-fire with their locally sustainable seasonal menu and the wall of greens....
|601 East New York Street, Indianapolis, IN, us

Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

Mama Carollas
Why We Love It: Mama Carolla's tosses up authentic Italian food in a romantic and quaint SoBro atmosphere. Dishes like the eggplant puttenesca, linguini with clam sauce and their lasagna make them an Indianapolis...
|1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN, us

Finch’s Brasserie

Why We Love It: This trendy location in Bloomington is a local favorite for families, couples and singles looking for a special setting to enjoy fine food and ambiance. The menu is inspired by the Slow Food movement...
|514 E Kirkwood Ave, Bloomington, IN, us
|(812) 333-2700


Why We Love It: A locally owned sharing plates restaurant and bar serving lunch and dinner Monday through Saturday for guests 21 and over. Divvy's contemporary American cuisine is served in a unique atmosphere and is...
|71 W. City Center Dr., Carmel, IN, us

St. Elmo's Steak House

Why We Love It: A retro steakhouse serving prime cuts, hearty sides and indulgent desserts. With a 30's throwback bar on the side, St. Elmo Steakhouse blends the best of classic MidWestern cuisine with a vintage...
|127 S Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN, us
|(317) 635-0636

Rail Epicurean Market

Why We Love It: Rail Epicurean Market provides an outlet for modern day food and beverage artisans to showcase their work. They use fresh, locally grown ingredients to make pastries, sandwiches, coffee, and tea.
|211 Park Street, Westfield, IN, us
|(317) 450-4981

Plow and Anchor Restaurant

Why We Love It: A top seafood destination in Downtown Indianapolis. Blending old world French and Spanish cuisine with a modern American twist, the menu is diverse but grounded in a love for the sea. Try their famous...
|43 E 9th St, Indianapolis, IN, us
|(317) 964-0538

1913 Restaurant

Why We Love It: 1913 is a rustic, farm to table restaurant in the heart of downtown Indianapolis. Located in the refined Omni Severin Hotel, built in 1913, this is dining inspired by the great heyday of early 1900s...
|Omni Severin Hotel, Indianapolis, IN, us
|(317) 396-3623

No Coast Reserve

No Coast Reserve Bloomington Oysters
Why We Love It: No Coast Reserve gives you a coastal menu in the Midwest. Daily oyster specials, lobster rolls, clams, shrimp and so much more fill the menu at this locally owned restaurant. They offer lunch and...
|105 College Ave, Bloomington, IN, us

Oakley’s Bistro

Why We Love It: Oakley's Bistro is an unpretentious American-meets-French bistro perfect for special occasions without the special price tag. Established in 2002 this restaurant is a firm favorite on the Indy food...
|1464 W 86th St , Indianapolis, IN, us
|(317) 824-1231


Why We Love It: Perfect portions and creativity are on offer at Recess in the Meridian Kessler neighborhood of Indianapolis. With an international menu boasting moist meats and fish as well as flavorful vegetable...
|4907 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN, us
|(317) 925-7529

What’s happening near you

February 03 | 8:00 PM - 10:00 PM

Bourbon and Bites

French Lick Resort
French Lick
Build your own subscription bundle.
Pick 3 regions for $60