Pies Galore: Where to Get Your Pie in Central Indiana

By Kylee Wierks | Last Updated November 07, 2014
Share to printerest Share to fb Share to twitter Share to mail Share to print

If there is one thing Hoosiers know how to make well, it’s pie. Fruit, meringue, cream—there’s a pie for everyone’s mood and taste buds. So when you’re in the mood for pie, check out one of these five homemade pie locations in central Indiana.

Bread Basket Cafe and Bakery

Why We Love It: Pies! The Bread Basket Cafe and Bakery uses organically grown produce from Stamper Farms & Gardens right down the street to make its pies. Bakers arrive at 5 a.m. to begin filling orders for the day....
|46 South Tennessee St., Danville, IN, us

My Sugar Pie

Why We Love It: My Sugar Pie has received national attention for its sugar pie from People Magazine, Oprah Magazine and Country Living Magazine. The Sugar Pie is also a signature treat at the Zionsville Farmers’...
|40 East Pine St., Zionsville, IN, us

Lisa’s Pie Shop

Why We Love It: Lisa Spark’s dream to start a pie shop began 18 years ago; she made pies out of her house for a year before they became popular enough for her to open shop. Lisa has nine different varieties of...
|5995 S US Highway 31, Atlanta, IN, us

Locally Grown Gardens

Why We Love It: Locally Grown Gardens is classically-trained chef Ron Harris' culinary foray into food markets and restaurants in one. With a rotating seasonal menu, legendary sugar cream and blueberry pies this...
|1050 E. 54th St., Indianapolis , IN, us
|(317) 255-8555

Mom’s Homemade Pies

Why We Love It: Mom’s Homemade Pies is one of the few pie shops in Indiana that makes its pie crust by hand. A mixer is never used at any stage of crust production. Owners Dave and Alyona Puckett say this is...
|3700B South LaFountain St., Kokomo, IN, us

Wick's Pie Inc.

Why We Love It: Beginning with hand production of twenty (20) pies per day, Wick's has now grown to producing a combination of over 10,000 pies and over 30,000 pie shells in an 8 hour production shift. In an average...
| 100 Cherry Street, Winchester, IN, us

What’s happening near you

Build your own subscription bundle.
Pick 3 regions for $60
We will never share your email address. Privacy Policy