Shop Local Bakeries in Central Indiana

Last Updated November 10, 2014
Share to printerest Share to fb Share to twitter Share to mail Share to print
Bread Basket Cafe Pie
Photo by Amy Phipps

3 Days in Paris - Market Fresh Crepes

Why We Love It: Go no further than 3 Days in Paris to savor the taste of freshly-baked Parisian crepes. From sweet to savory, 3 Days in Paris’ downtown location makes for the perfect brunch spot. Fuel your farmer...
|222 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN, us
|(317) 674-5602

BeeFree Gluten-Free Bakery

Why We Love It: All BeeFree Gluten-Free Bakery products are made with all natural and gluten-free ingredients. Items are made in a carefully controlled kitchen with specially selected ingredients free from gluten and...
|176 W. Logan St. #311, Noblesville, IN, us

Bowman Bakery

Why We Love It: Bowman Bakery has been preparing delectable treats in Hagerstown for years. They only use fresh, all-natural ingredients and everything is made from scratch. They’re best-selling item is their...
|48 S Perry St, Hagerstown, IN, us

Bread Basket Cafe and Bakery

Why We Love It: Pies! The Bread Basket Cafe and Bakery uses organically grown produce from Stamper Farms & Gardens right down the street to make its pies. Bakers arrive at 5 a.m. to begin filling orders for the day....
|46 South Tennessee St., Danville, IN, us

Circle City Sweets & Circle City Soups

Why We Love It: Featuring a selection of hot, fresh breakfast and lunch items Circle City Sweets is most definitely for the sugary-toothed. Pick up a muffin, brioche, seasonal jam or order an inventive wedding cake...
|222 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN, us
|(317) 632-3644

Concannon’s Bakery Café

Why We Love It: Concannon’s has been a Muncie staple for decades. They sell every baked good imaginable: cakes, cupcakes, breads, cookies, donuts, candied popcorn, and chocolates. Their coffee cake is one of their...
|4801 W Baker Ln, Muncie, IN, us

Feast Bakery Cafe & Catering

Why We Love It: Sisters Erika Yochum & Jennifer Burt opened Feast in 2010. Erika is the head chef. They are long-time farmers market vendors, and they support and benefit from local farmers and ranchers. They hold...
|581 E. Hillside Dr. Suite 104, Bloomington, us

Grabow Orchard & Bakery

Why We Love It: Grabow Orchard and Bakery is a must-visit orchard in the fall in cozy Pendleton. The orchard features 25 varieties of apples, a u-pick pumpkin patch, and a myriad of different fresh produce for sale....
|Pendleton, IN, us

Lisa’s Pie Shop

Why We Love It: Lisa Spark’s dream to start a pie shop began 18 years ago; she made pies out of her house for a year before they became popular enough for her to open shop. Lisa has nine different varieties of...
|5995 S US Highway 31, Atlanta, IN, us

Locally Grown Gardens

Why We Love It: Locally Grown Gardens is classically-trained chef Ron Harris' culinary foray into food markets and restaurants in one. With a rotating seasonal menu, legendary sugar cream and blueberry pies this...
|1050 E. 54th St., Indianapolis , IN, us
|(317) 255-8555

Mom’s Homemade Pies

Why We Love It: Mom’s Homemade Pies is one of the few pie shops in Indiana that makes its pie crust by hand. A mixer is never used at any stage of crust production. Owners Dave and Alyona Puckett say this is...
|3700B South LaFountain St., Kokomo, IN, us

Muddy Fork Farm and Bakery

Why We Love It: Muddy Fork Farm & Bakery uses local and organic ingredients to bake delicious breads in a homemade brick, wood-fired oven. All of their whole-wheat flour, honey and eggs are locally grown and raised,...
|4569 Earl Young Rd, Bloomington, IN, us

My Sugar Pie

Why We Love It: My Sugar Pie has received national attention for its sugar pie from People Magazine, Oprah Magazine and Country Living Magazine. The Sugar Pie is also a signature treat at the Zionsville Farmers’...
|40 East Pine St., Zionsville, IN, us

Pat-a-Cakes and Cookies Too

Why We Love It: The two owners of Pat-a-Cakes and Cookies Too have nearly 50 years of combined experience in the baking and cake decorating industry. They offer all kinds of special goodies for different seasons and...
|5649 Pebble Village Lane, Noblesville, IN, us
|11679 Olio Road, Fishers, IN, us

Rainbow Bakery

Why We Love It: Rainbow Bakery is an all vegan bakery. They sell 39 different flavors of cakes and cupcakes including chai spice, early grey, pink lemonade and pamplemousse. All of their flavors can also be made...
|4th and Rogers St, Bloomington, IN, us

The Porch

Why We Love It: Surround yourself with books at this cozy tea room / organic café. The Porch serves made-from scratch lunch and desserts, along with over 50 different teas. Customers loves their award-winning...
|2411 E Main St., Danville, IN, us
|(317) 745-5792

Scholars Inn, Restaurant and Bakehouse

Why We Love It: The Scholars Inn Bakehouse is a Bloomington staple with delicious breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert options. They use all-natural, local ingredients and everything is under $10. And they are the...
|125 N. College Ave., Bloomington, IN, us

Shapiro’s Delicatessen & Bakery

Why We Love It: Shapiro’s Bakery is part of Shapiro’s Delicatessen in downtown Indianapolis. They have been serving Kosher-Style Favorites in their original location for almost 110 years. When you walk into...
|808 S Meridian , Indianapolis, IN, us

Spencer Farm

Why We Love It: The Spencer Farm, established in 1982, is home to “more than just berries.” The Noblesville farm started as a berry farm but has since expanded to offer a wider variety of produce and other food...
|7177 East 161st Street, Noblesville, IN, us
|(317) 776-1560

Titus Bakery

Why We Love It: Originating in the 1950’s, Titus Bakery is a third-generation, family-owned business that has earned a reputation for providing some of the finest treats in the state. Best known for its doughnuts,...
|820 W South St, Lebanon, IN, us


|4750 Broadway St, Indianapolis, IN, us

Wilson Farm Market

Why We Love It: Wilson Farm Market sells a lot of amish products, including Yoder meats, Amish cheeses, jams and jellies, bulk foods. They make fresh fudge and bake fresh breads and cookies everyday. Open Daily from...
|1720 E 256th St, Arcadia, IN, us

What’s happening near you

Build your own subscription bundle.
Pick 3 regions for $60
We will never share your email address. Privacy Policy